Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by eternalban 5211 days ago
I do not like that line of thinking! Per your view, the employer can then claim your "thoughts" outside of the office as their "property". Anytime someone puts a[n] employment agreement that claims right to all my intellectual output while employed I say "Thanks, but no thanks."
2 comments

My experience is that many, many contracts for programmer-types include a clause about intellectual property. In my direct experience, no employer has ever collected on this. I suspect if an employer did exercise it, it would be for IP directly related to their business/product. But...that's a hope, not necessarily a reality.
My last employer actually said something along the same thing during negotiations. I countered with "then why even have it in the contract?". He was a reasonable man.

Also that whole "related to their business" is over-reach as well. If I work for (say) a database company and am providing quality work but spend my nights at home designing a new kind of database, what possible (reasonable) claim can the employer have on my private work? All this and yet we are "employed at will".

> Per your view, the employer can then claim your "thoughts" outside of the office as their "property".

Yah, and in fact that is exactly what they do. Usually they make you give them a list of any prior inventions you already have, and they claim ownership of everything else.

Obviously you can negotiate and not sign it, but it's pretty typical clause.