Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dcow 1042 days ago
Your comment is slightly self-contradictory.

First you say it's really important to prosecute all crime because justice is about the response to crime.

Then you say it's silly to be worried that a bunch of "small crime" (furthermore, there's nothing to indicate in this case that this is a small crime) goes unpunished all the time.

Which one is it? Do we care about crime or don't we? I'd say it's actually the little crimes going unpunished that worry me the most... car theft, shoplifting, etc. These signal to participants that it's okay to behave in a way that is not in line with the stated laws of the land. Building this safe space for petty crime is far more dangerous than having a one-off corrupt asshole who committed a more "serious" crime run free on a legal technicality, because the safe-space normalizes bad behavior and desensitizes society to crime.

1 comments

I understood parent to be making an observation about timescales.

In the short term, there is and will be overreach by law enforcement and prosecution.

In the intermediate/long term, we should recognize these incidents and ensure redress is made and justice is brought.

Which seems a pretty reasonable position:

- People need flexibility to do their jobs

- We should have robust oversight to review actions taken

- We should consider irreversible actions extremely seriously (or prevent them outright)