Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jgalt212 1048 days ago
Dumb question: If these apps offer end-to-end encryption, how is anyone getting caught?
1 comments

Lots of ways:

- A banker answers honestly when interviewed by the regulator because they decide it's better for the Bank to take the fine than lie to regulator and risk personal criminal charges (unlikely, but why take that risk?).

- Regulator asks for evidence of some documentation (like trade confirmation), compliance asks banker, banker doesn't have it and admits it was over this app.

- Whistleblower or other source makes regulator believe there are prohibited communication and regulator demands phones be turned over.

- Other similar banks are caught in violation, and regulator does sweep of similar banks and demands phones be turned over.

The regulator has the ability to shut down the bank. The bank can easily tell the banker to turn over an unlocked phone or face legal action. The banker then turns over the phone.

I'd delete all my messages before doing any of that. I'm not one for deceiving the regulators, but for lack of a better term when it comes to compliance, they cannot handle the truth.
For what it's worth, that's a path towards obstruction charges.