Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Snafuh 1038 days ago
How much are they making in Norway? Why would global revenue/profit be relevant for a fine in Norway about Norwegian users?
1 comments

Because GDPR accounts for fines to be relative to global turnover https://gdpr-info.eu/issues/fines-penalties/
That doesn't mean it should always be applied. We shouldn't be attempting to annihilate companies. Just make sure the fine outweighs the benefit of doing something - just as we would with most fines.
I am not sure we shouldn't try to annihilate companies, is a good strategy, or at least not for any company, Meta is useless for society and constantly lying, stealing, omitting, exploiting, endangering, we shouldn't be willing to annihilate companies who make mistakes, probably we should aim to annihilate companies which consistently behave at the edge of civilization
I don't think it's up to you to decide if Meta is useless to society (which society? There are many). If it vanished it would be a huge problem for many societies. That implies it's not useless.
Of course it's not up to me, I am entitled to my opinion, it's implying that each phrase ends as IMHO (OR we need to make it explicit? Are we that bad? Can a single expose an idea that isn't his own?)

But yeah it's not up to me, but history is history

https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-64075067 or https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32018149/

I'm not in the mood of self-inflicting pain to go back to each scandal related to meta, but I guess these are quite heavy examples of the contribution of this company to society(ies?)

Sure, but what doesn't make the news is two billion people were able to communicate with infra that didn't buckle during a global pandemic, for example. Calling that useless is...I dunno. Quite something.
Is there an instance where this was actually applied?

We read about privacy related fines here and there, but none really seem to take into account the global revenue

As European I've lived through the crisis of 2008, when people were killing themselves due to lack of money and the only concern of EU was pleasing markets, save banks without any repercussions to those who caused all that pain, etc.

I am aware that EU is a PR stunt, probably will make some regulation here and there, but nothing exceptional, it's still a neoliberal/corporativist sewer at the end of the day

Norway isn’t in the EU.
Yeah, I mean, it is part of EEA, pays for the access to common market, respects the EU directives, but has no saying, but that doesn't like make big difference