[dav-id]

If I recall correctly he didnt break any laws in the UK.

[mrkmcknz]

Correct because in the UK members of parliament are not elected to represent the complete morons at the MPAA and RIAA.

[andylei]

that's not what the judge thought. from the article in the telegraph:

> The defence believed its strongest argument against extradition was that Mr O'Dwyer had not committed an offence under British law

> However, Judge Purdy rejected the argument

[grecy]

I read that to mean the judge is not saying he broke British laws, just that not breaking British laws is not a valid argument.

[andylei]

i don't think your reading is correct. one of the basic principles of extradition agreements is that the law broken has to apply in both countries