[kapilvt]

I was using wolfi for an oss project, but the recent attempts at forcing payments when pinning version was a huge red flag, as was the messaging around it, and I’ll be migrating away from it.

https://www.chainguard.dev/unchained/scaling-chainguard-imag...

Pinning a language version (say python 3.11) isn’t an optional thing its a best practice, and the notion that its because of security seems intentionally misleading as the images should be refreshed in place on the tag along with signatures.

[amouat]

I'm very sorry that we broke things for you.

To be clear, nothing has changed with Wolfi. Wolfi is an open source community project and everything is still available there: https://github.com/wolfi-dev/.

We have made changes to Chainguard Images - our commercial product built on top of Wolfi - which mean you can no longer pull images by tag (other than latest). Chainguard images are rebuilt everyday and have a not inconsiderable maintenance cost (and the money we make here directly helps us support Wolfi).

The easiest way to avoid this is to build the images yourself. You can rebuild identical images to ours using apko and the source files in the images repo e.g: https://github.com/chainguard-images/images/blob/main/images... (note you can replace package names with versioned versions). You can also just use a Dockerfile with the wolfi-base image to "apk add" packages. Full details are here: https://www.chainguard.dev/unchained/a-guide-on-how-to-use-c...

I agree that pinning is a best practice. The above blog explains that you can still do it using a digest, but I accept this isn't the simplest solution.

If I can help any more, please feel free to get in touch - you can find me most places including twitter https://twitter.com/adrianmouat

[kapilvt]

I sympathize, but if wolfi is oss, please update docs and downloads to use a separate registry then your commercial one for distribution.

else, frankly you claimed wolfi is oss, get customers to use your registry, and then bait and switched your early adopters.

aka, major version upgrades at random, have fun!

[amouat]

Wolfi packages are served from https://packages.wolfi.dev/os which can be used with apk tools or apko.

The built Chainguard images are all on the cgr.dev registry.

Wolfi is completely OSS.

The policies regarding Chainguard Images have changed over time, so if there are docs that don't properly reflect this, please let me know and I'll get them updated.

[kapilvt]

let me rephrase that, wolfi is an oss container image distro without an image, you get to pay us for the image. but here's a our tooling cause we like to call it oss, have fun building. either have those oss images on a non commercial registry, or let's stop misleading folks about what this is, aka pay to play/use oci images. that all wolfi docs / blog posts reference a commercial registry while touting it as oss, is the definition of bait and switch.