Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by applesan 1055 days ago
I don't understand, how is that different from just using chatgpt?

Generally I don't think it is good idea to use LLMs for learning languages, especially if it wasn't trained primarily on that language. Also if you are beginner, how can you know if what it says is even correct?

From my experience, it makes a lot of mistakes (at least in Japanese and Polish).

2 comments

I'm wondering the same thing about a lot of these GPT powered products. I really would like to see more products leverage the technology, but they need to truly differentiate themselves from just throwing in a halfway clever prompt into the chat tool.

Where I could see this differentiation occur is where you add some data permanence and data organization around what has been chatted about. For example, could the tutor create a quiz for you that is not in chat, format or you can actually click on little bubbles to choose from a multiple-choice question and have a grade you at the end with some nice formatting and visual detail? Maybe it gives you a chart of how you're progressing over time...that sort of thing.

Maybe it has a separate area where it is keeping homework assignments for you or just making a course outline that you can follow along and monitor your progress day by day.

I could see myself using this if it had a composition feature where I could do some free form writing and it could make edits in place as another example. All of this could be GPT powered.

At the end of the day, the fact that you can chat with it shouldn't be the breakthrough feature because nowadays, this is a "just expected"

It depends a lot on the language. For Spanish and English it's good, but they make up a large portion of the internet.