Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jacquesm 1053 days ago
I really hate to start quoting basic wikipedia articles but I have some other stuff to do and I don't want to leave this dangling, from:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_field

This is the second sentence in that article:

"Electric fields originate from electric charges and time-varying electric currents."

> I keep bringing the circuit theory in because it is the reason why people can't believe how electricity actually works.

Circuit theory is simply a very useful approximation and how 'electricity actually works' is highly counter intuitive because for starters we got the flow of electrons wrong (they flow from - to + and not the other way around). Still, conceptually, everybody that does electronics for a living will model the flow from + to - because of convenience. But strictly speaking that's not how it 'really works'. But nobody cares they just have a job to do and the tools that suffice for that are the tools that will be used.

Finally: the QM reconciliation of EM and Gravity is for now an unsolved problem so there is a fair chance that in the long run you'll be able to make the argument that 'EM is not really how it works'. But for now it's good enough.