Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bastawhiz 1057 days ago
> Not one killer app has emerged.

I'll say that I pretty firmly disagree with this. I've been using Github Copilot for about six months for my own work and it has fundamentally changed how I write code. Ignoring the ethics of Copilot, if I just need to read a file with some data, parse it, and render that data on screen, Copilot just _does_ most of that for me. I write a chunky comment explaining what I want, it writes a blob of code that I tab through, and I'm left with a nicely-documented, functioning piece of software. A one-off script that took me 30 minutes to write previously now takes me maybe a minute on a bad day.

For ages we've had Text Expander and key mappings and shortcuts and macros that render templates of pre-built code. Now I can just say what I'm trying to do, the language model considers the other code on the page, and it gets done.

If this isn't a "killer app" then I'm not sure what is. In my entire career I can think of maybe two things that I've come upon that have affected my workflow this much: source control and continuous integration. Which, frankly, is wild.

Separately, I use LLMs to generate marketing copy for my side hustle. I suck at marketing, but I can tell the damn thing what I want to market and it gives me a list of tweets back that sound like the extroverted CMO that I don't have. I can outsource creative tasks like brainstorming lists of names for products, or coming up with text categories for user feedback from a spreadsheet. I don't know if I'd call either of those things "killer apps" but I have a tool which can do thinking for me at a nominal cost, quickly, and with a high-enough quality bar that it's usually not a waste of my time.

1 comments

My friend made a great comparison that seems to agree with your take: chatGPT for coding is like when ruby on rails came out. Or wordpress. felt magical and boosted (a certain kind of) productivity through the roof.

We don't think of rails as the second coming though.

same with code editors. of course a rails for all of code is cool. but iono, it's a code editor. i still use sublime.

I'd maybe make the analogy that it's like the first ORM. Sure, you could write your own DB queries, but it just does what you want, and it's usually right.

Were ORMs the second coming? Meh. But it's arguable that they're still immensely powerful and useful and the way people write apps that interface with an RDBMS is permanently changed forevermore.

How did WordPress boost productivity? Fussing with hosting, CMS, plug-ins is a mess. I just went back to good old hand written HTML with pico.css. Got my site down from 8mb to 100kb
Most people cannot write good old hand written HTML; when WordPress came out and picked up stream, it was the biggest thing to hit the web hosting industry since FrontPage.