[pfdietz]

That's a good story, but is there any evidence for it?

We know simple building blocks can be created, in low concentrations, with large amounts of other components that don't end up in life. The concentration of any given chemical in this mix is exponentially dependent on its complexity. The "once a short chain is formed, it will (slowly) replicate" is entirely unsupported by experiment. Indeed, it's difficult to see how it could work, when it's replicating in a soup loaded with junk monomers.