Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by unmole 1062 days ago
Slavery, extortion and kidnapping are not scams though. And you'll notice that in all these cases the victims would have been better off if their tormentor simply did not exist. Would employees be better off if their employer didn't exist?

> This system is definitely rigged.

How would a hypothetical non-rigged system look like?

2 comments

> Would employees be better off if their employer didn't exist?

well, we're talking about Meta here

> well, we're talking about Meta here

And? Why would Meta employees be better off if Meta didn't exist?

It's hard to see into alternative worlds. I can tell you what my belief is, but I can't really prove it: if Meta did not exist (and no other similar company filled the same niche), the world would be better by most measurements. People would, on average, be happier.

People in general are better off living in a better world.

And most Meta Employees would have found other jobs. I mean, sure, in this alternate world some specific people would be worse off. I would wager they would be the minority by far.

Let me know if you get a timeline-scope and we can verify.

> Meta did not exist (and no other similar company filled the same niche), the world would be better by most measurements.

Why would a company filling a similar niche be better for the world? I'm not asking for proof, just for reasoning beyond wishful thinking.

I think you misread my comment. What I meant is that I'm not only assuming Meta does not exist, but also assuming that no other company that fills the same niche exists. If there's another company which is essentially the same, just with another name and minor differences, it doesn't change much.
>Would employees be better off if their employer didn't exist?

Absolutely.

Yeah, it's so much better to not have a job. /s
The fact your employer wouldn't exist in an alternate reality doesn't mean you wouldn't have a job in that same alternate reality.
The comment I responded to claimed all employment was a scam. The hypothetical being considered was not of an alternative employer.
Yes, because a FAANG dev would end up jobless and homeless if their employer went under /s
The comment I responded to claimed all employment was a scam.