Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by enneff 1073 days ago
This is an interesting tangent. I agree that advertisers lie, and that some actors that appear in advertisements speak lies.

But I don’t think Matt Damon was lying when he portrayed Jason Bourne; nobody was under the impression that Bourne is a real person. They even put “Matt Damon” on the screen at the beginning so nobody is confused.

1 comments

Framed differently, they put Matt Damon on the screen first because he is lying and they don’t want anyone to be confused about it.
“They” in this case includes Damon himself. It’s not some separate group of people protecting the audience from Damon’s deceit. If I say to you “I am acting as a character” and then proceed to do so, where is the lie?

Similarly, if I say to you “This is nonsense: Water does not exist” was I lying as I spoke the last four words? Context is kinda important I think.