Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by flohofwoe 1072 days ago
Tell me an alternative which ticks all the checkboxes and I'll switch immediately. C++ isn't it because the committee has completely lost focus since ca C++11, Rust isn't it because they completely forgot about ergonomics, simplicity and elegance on their quest to fix memory safety (and both C++ and Rust suffer from "design by committee").

Zig looks perfect so far, but it's too early to switch over yet.

Any other promising candidates?
2 comments
versteegen 1072 days ago
You didn't say what the checkboxes are, but... perhaps the 'BetterC' subset of D? https://dlang.org/spec/betterc.html#retained

Or D itself if you don't need a language as minimal as C. D is basically C++ redesigned and now that GCC includes D support by default I wonder whether it'll gain popularity.

link
flohofwoe 1072 days ago
Definitely an option, and D is actually one of the languages I haven't seriously looked into yet (or rather, I saw it as a C++ alternative in its heydays ca 2005 and that image stuck in my head - and at that time I hadn't been looking for a C++ alternative)

PS: my main use of C is currently to write platform abstraction libraries with minimal size and runtime overhead, so need to talk directly to operating system APIs, plus WASM is a very important target. The libraries must be usable from other languages via automatic bindings generation (quite simple with a C API). Also for performance-oriented stuff, direct control over memory layout and lifetimes please.

Also personal opinion from 20 years of C++ experience: high level abstractions never pay off in the long run. Simple imperative code always wins when it comes to "malleability".

link
9659 1072 days ago
Ada. 83 or 95
link
flohofwoe 1072 days ago
Interesting choice, but Ada is probably even less popular than Zig.

Even just requiring users to integrate my hypophetical Ada library source distribution into their project's build system files would most likely drown me in support tickets ;)

link
pjmlp 1072 days ago
It certainly has more production deployments than Zig might ever get.
link
pjmlp 1072 days ago
We are in Ada 2012 nowadays, with Ada 202x getting finalized.

https://www.adaic.org/advantages/ada-202x/

link
9659 1068 days ago
my point is either of these versions are very complete and usable implementations. more recent is even better.
link