|
|
|
|
|
|
by lifeonlars
1074 days ago
|
|
|
Almost any web server can be configured to provide a generic response to a specific request, for example by ignoring some or all of the url path, and in practice I would bet that a majority of actual instances do this for at least some sets of requests. (To confirm my theory in 20 seconds I checked if https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=nonexistent_user_1620 returns a 404 or a 200 - it's the latter.) It's silly to pretend that the use of a 404 in this type of circumstance is either clearcut in the standards or ubiquitous in practice. |
|
|
The standards seem pretty clear to me.
I would point out that technically, the path portion of the HN URI does indeed point to a valid endpoint, it is the query portion of the URI (usually not used by the server to do any routing) that points to a non-existent resource.
Still, HN is wrong here and should be returning a 404 status.