Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by exDM69 1072 days ago
WoodRiver is a US brand for tools manufactured by Quangsheng tools in China. They are sold all over the world under different brand names. In the past few years, a similar factory has emerged in India with lots of different brands selling them.

They make decent tools. I'm sure the US and Canadian premium tools (LN and LV) are better but at least in Europe the price difference (after taxes and customs) is steep and difficult to justify.

2 comments

Preach. I got a Lie Nielsen shipped to Germany. I'll only get another if I can buy it in-person during vacation, beat it up a little to look used, and bring it back in checked luggage without the original packaging.

Illegal? yes. Immoral? I'm not so sure.

Customs is ridiculous. DHL tacks on a 6 Euro fee if VAT isn't prepaid. Sellers often list the RRP instead of the paid price. (Newsflash: if I payed less than RRP, that was the market price when I bought it, so that should be the price listed on the CN 23!)

I paid more than twice what I should have on the last package I got from the U.S. It was on sale for 30% off, but the seller listed the RRP, which, plus delivery costs, put it over the threshold for adding customs fees. Adding on the post office's fee, it was 56 or 58 euros rather than 24 or 25 had they simply prepaid EU VAT on the charged amount. All this I know, because I also bought their competitor's product for essentially the same price, but the competitor (admitted, a much larger business) had a global delivery partner to handle the shipping and taxes.

I'd get a metal Ulmia or a KUNZ-plus if they didn't require work getting them true and sharp. I'd get a knockoff if the knockoff brands start to innovate and introduce new designs. With Veritas, Lie Nielsen, and Clifton, I know I'm supporting innovative small businesses and owning functional art that maintains its resale value after decades of heavy use.

> In the past few years, a similar factory has emerged in India with lots of different brands selling them.

Do you happen to know the name of the factory or any of the brands?

Perhaps Anant? I can say from experience that Anant is not remotely equal in quality to QuangSheng.