Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by LiberalArtist 1086 days ago
> But that is also merely a JS only forum, so not ideal. There used to be the Google groups thingy including a mailing list. Google, so not ideal either. But at least it had a mailing list.

I was a long-time skeptic of moving away from the Google Groups list, so I try to be equally vocal in saying that the move to Discourse was handled really well IMO. In fact it is not "a JS-only forum": you do need to sign up in the web UI, but, after that, you can put it in "mailing-list mode" and ignore the website completely, including for starting new threads (see <https://racket.discourse.group/t/how-to-enable-mailing-list-...>). The email interface is important to many Racketeers; if other Discourse instances don't enable it, that's their admin's choice. The Google Groups list had been rendered nearly unusable by spam, and it was never free and open-source software, which Discourse is. (I wrote more detailed thoughts at the time in <https://groups.google.com/g/racket-users/c/RnIAQnZpvh0/m/A78...>.)

On the other hand, I share some of your concerns about Discord (the similar names are unfortunate). But there was never an organized "move to Discord": some people just started talking about Racket there, as people had before, and still do, on IRC and Slack and all sorts of places. People are also regularly nudged to move non-transient conversations to searchable and archived venues.

1 comments

Thanks for the heads up regarding mailing list mode of Discourse. I will consider that!