Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by looofooo 1092 days ago
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chappe_telegraph

Might be cheaper to build an Tower with PV and battery every 30km than running lines.

Cell-Tower in remote Locations etc.

1 comments

Congrats, you've reinvented microwave lines, widely deployed in exactly this manner.
The big difference between open air laser and microwave links is that one of them doesn't require licensed spectrum. The costs of doing it will be much lower.
Fair! And the existing MW re-translator towers can be upgraded / reused this way.

Lasers have a downside though: optical and near IR light is much more readily absorbed by water vapor than microwaves. I wonder if a maser would be an acceptable solution, if cheaper versions of it existed.

1550nm water is super transparent.
Not at all.

While 1550 nm falls between two absorption maxima of water, so it is not the worst choice, the absorption in water is still more than one hundred times higher than at e.g. 905 nm.

Because of this, 1550 nm is absorbed through fog or clouds at least 3 to 5 times more than shorter wavelengths like 905 nm. Even the latter is absorbed a lot by water, while being much more dangerous for eyes than 1550 nm.

There is no near infrared wavelength where the water absorption is negligible.

See the graphs at:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromagnetic_absorption_by_...

I'm sure regulators will start regulating the 1550nm spectrum once they realize they can start making money off free space optics.
Right, because there's no reason at all to regulate a shared medium like RF bands except to make money.
Microwave is also slow compared to this.