[ImPostingOnHN]

"obviously broken" is a straw man because we're just discussing anything that doesn't satisfy everything you want (which you listed).

indeed, the concept of an "obviously broken" MVP is an oxymoron, since V stands for "viable"

when giving everybody everything they want becomes the priority, then "not perfect" stuff just gets re-dubbed "obviously broken" by 1 random person, which is actually the problem: it's better to ship something and get feedback and iterate on it than to ship nothing or to ship the wrong thing after a long development time or to ship at the end of however long it takes to satisfy everybody's desires