Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tourmalinetaco 1094 days ago
BitWarden didn’t lose any of my passwords (which is what I assume you meant by “corner cases”), and their UX on Chromium and iOS are about on par with LastPass, so I’m not quite sure the difficulties you may have experienced. And while BitWarden’s iOS app isn’t well optimized, considering its a FOSS solution I am more than happy with that minor trade-off. I also haven’t had any trouble moving others onto it, even the more tech-illiterate people in my life.

It’s certainly not perfect, but I’m not quite sure these issues are consistent enough to be indicative of BitWarden’s quality. I mean if its lost your passwords I would assume that’s something worth making an issue about on their GitHub?
2 comments
moogly 1094 days ago
LastPass' CSV export can't handle certain characters so the exported password is wrong. I doubt they've fixed that. It was in the product during the 10-12 years I used LastPass.
link
dp-hackernews 1094 days ago
Worse than that, LP notes are multi line which makes importing a bloody nightmare! Especially if you have any CSV characters in the note.

I had to modify the native CSV with some vim magic to add a line delimiter for each record so it allowed for spanning over multiple lines in order to successfully import each entry - which also required the importer to allow for an additional EOR marker.

Even then there wasn't a 1:1 column match between pw apps.

Without this step though all sorts of hell breaks loose, and if you don't notice the columns got out of sync during import because a note had a few commas in it what good is it to you really. It's a hell of a mess that you may not notice until its too late.

There should also be a verify feature for any import that can query the original source via some API calls - or use that to do the import. Of course nobody is going to provide that because it means users can leave their ecosystem too easily - but the other thinking is customized backups to a PGP destination suitable for direct import via the sale API calls.

This was for LP to KeePass BTW.

link
suddenclarity 1094 days ago
> BitWarden didn’t lose any of my passwords

Do we know that considering how they handle iframes and how lax they seem about it?

link