Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jmwilson 1100 days ago
There are metal replacement toners that replace the silver in a print with either gold or platinum. This way the print can be made normally with an enlarger and silver chemistry to overcome the contact printing limitation. Toning improves the longevity of the print and provides many of the same tonal effects, depending on how long the print sits in the bath. Unfortunately, the chemicals involved are quite toxic. I remember one of the instructors at the Rayko darkroom in San Francisco running a "toning day" and it was very busy with a number of people coming in to tone their work and share the considerable material and hazmat fees for the chemicals.

"unlike silver gelatin prints that hold the chemicals in a layer on top of the paper, platinum photography uses chemicals that are soaked into the paper, so the image lies embedded in its fibers."

Fiber paper for silver prints is also a thing, and easily available from commercial sources. It requires more extensive washing compared to RC (resin coated) paper, and it tends to curl and warp after wetting. To get prints flat after drying, you need a big heated press that looks like a giant panini maker.

6 comments

I think selinium toning is like this, and that's definitely in the dubious stuff you really don't want to get on your skin category. The prints do look gorgeous after selinium toning though!

And I agree, fibre paper is awesome but the drying and mounting process tends to be onerous compared to resin coated paper, so I rarely do it. Saying that, I do happen to have a 16*20 capable heated paper press, but compared to fibre, there really is no contest for convenience!

Fibre prints are however still a layer on the surface, usually over the top of a baryta (barium sulphite) layer that acts as a white base. Platinum-Palladium prints really are soaked into the fibre of your paper.
>Rayko

I got into film photography too late to ever visit Rayko. How I wish it had survived, somehow. Having a whole darkroom for rent in town would be incredible.

San Francisco has the Harvey Milk Photo Center, which has a huge dark room and film processing facilities. It's pretty awesome. I've taken several classes there. https://www.harveymilkphotocenter.org/
In case anyone from central Indiana stumbles upon this thread, the Indianapolis Art Center also has a darkroom with inexpensive classes. I’m anxiously awaiting my next class this fall.

https://indyartcenter.org/

Wow, thank you! Sounds like I can even learn how to use the darkroom there. Boy, I love that we have stuff like this here. Shoutout to Oscar’s in SOMA for doing a great job developing my stuff for me, fwiw.
Absolutely. There are regular darkroom classes you can sign up for. It's kind of hard to get a spot because the classes are small but my teacher said people also have learned how on YouTube and then come in to practice.
> many of the same tonal effects,

The toners don't replace the silver so much as alter or supplement it. I used selenium back in the 80s and the (fiber paper) prints so treated have held up almost perfectly. The tonal difference it very subtle. Mounting them on archival board or storing them in neutral buffered paper boxes is essential for maximum longevity.

I have a book that is only about photographic toners. I think that’s where I read that many vintage “platinum” prints are actually platinum toned Kallitypes. Still platinum on the paper in the end.
Could you share the book details?
Sorry for the late reply. Holy cow this thing got expensive! https://www.amazon.com/Photographers-Toning-Book-Definitive-...

It is the most comprehensive guide to toners I have ever seen. Glad I kept a copy of it!

Any vendors of toner replacement chem you could pass along?
I've used kodak selenium toner, this stuff: https://www.ag-photolab.co.uk/product/kodak-rapid-selenium-t...

I've also used tetenal for sepia style prints, their sulphide toner. Not a metal toner, but produces interesting and long lasting prints, this stuff: https://tetenal.com/en/homepage/consumer-shop/black-white-ch...

Tetenal make great C41 and E6 chemistry too if this is your thing.

Kodak & Ilford sell regular selenium toners, and https://stores.photoformulary.com/toners/ for more exotic stuff
Photographers' Formulary is your place <https://stores.photoformulary.com/>