Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by powertower 5230 days ago
The post seems to be confusing .NET Framework with VS.NET plug-in api/framework.

VS.NET is the IDE you use for .NET programming. Nothing else even compares.

Saying this...

> Visual Studio 11 will be the sixth iteration of Visual Studio with .net support. And it’s still a terrible platform for the .net programmer.

...is at serious odds with my own reality.
2 comments
jbevain 5230 days ago
I hope it makes more sense if you replace this snippet in the context of the post.

Visual Studio is a great IDE for the .net programmer.

It's terrible as a platform for which you build managed addins/plugins.

link
Yarnage 5230 days ago
Yeah this article greatly confused me as to what the author was upset about. Was it the Visual Studio extensibility? .Net? Visual Studio itself?

From the context of the article I'm pretty sure the author is upset at the Visual Studio extensibility (and rightfully so) but I'm still confused when he made statements about it driving .Net developers away; I'd imagine less than a quarter of .Net developers actually even THINK about extending any VS functions.

link
jbevain 5230 days ago
Obviously I failed at conveying my point. Greatly sorry about that.

I think it's mad that in 2012, it's so hard to extend Visual Studio using C# and .net.

I'm not saying it drives .net developers away. I'm saying it hurts the .net platform as a whole.

Would VS's extensibility be easier, with better APIs and documentations, we would see a lot more third party plugins to improve our programming experience with VS.

link
kevin_morrill 5229 days ago
I worked for Microsoft on Visual Studio extensibility back in the early days of .NET. At the time it was ground breaking and exciting that there was finally one IDE for using all of Microsoft's programming languages with no hidden APIs. The IDE is now long overdue for a rewrite in .NET, but it would be such a massive undertaking. So far the business benefit of that has yet to eclipse the cost.
link
jbevain 5229 days ago
Note that I'm not asking for VS to be rewritten. I actually don't think it would make a lot of sense.

I'm simply asking for good bindings, well documented and respecting the expectations (API wise) of a managed programmer.

link