[gmac]

Yes, this particular example I always find really stark.

Large numbers of people look at a VW and think to themselves: "this is a nice car, but what I really want is to pay a whole lot more for it".

(I have a SEAT, which is for people who think the reverse. VAG, so same engine, transmission, gearbox, software, etc. as VW, Audi, Skoda).

[Ccecil]

A Audi/VW mechanic I know put it best "They all mostly use the same parts so maintenance and repairs cost the same...might as well buy the one that sells for more used"

It depends on what you want. If you are planning to resell the car after a certain length of time the best bet is the Audi. If you are buying used and want "close" to the same performance buy VW (Audi has higher power, often different suspension, better sound deadening and way more options).

In my case...I bought a used VW. So I didn't take the advice...but I don't ever plan on reselling. I repair cars myself and run them far longer than a typical person does. By the time I am done with my car it will probably be sold for scrap due to miles...even though everything will likely be replaced at least once.

[gmac]

> “might as well buy the one that sells for more used

Not sure I follow this logic. Seems unlikely the higher resale value is going to fully cover the higher price you buy it for (whether you buy new or used)?

[Ccecil]

I guess "hold their value longer" is a better wording...but that is the point.

Easier to sell used? More desirable/rare? He bought/fixed and resold mostly Audi/VW but specialized in European cars.

I have owned 2 VW and 1 Audi. They all had very similar intervals on things breaking. I will say though I much preferred to drive the Audi...but unfortunately a 2001 allroad only lasts so long :)

[newaccount74]

If you follow that logic, then the Dacia Sandero is the only car you can buy. Every other car just comes with pointless overpriced extras that nobody needs.

In reality, the brand of a car is extremely important to most people who buy cars.

(But speaking of VW transmissions, I don't know why anyone would buy a VW. Their manuals always seem to be having issues with the clutch, and DSG is the worst driving experience I've ever had. Maybe their EVs work better)

[gmac]

Not really. The point is that all these VAG brands share technology and key parts.

A Dacia is an old Renault, built cheaply. A VW Golf, a Skoda Octavia, a SEAT Leon and an Audi A3 are mostly the same car.

[prmoustache]

I knew a guy who had been working on a VW/Audi manufacturing line in Belgium. I think they were assembling golf and A3. Both models were assembled on the same line, I wouldn't vouch that all posts were exactly assembling same parts, that wouldn't be true, especially as fit and finish and some specs are different, but for his particular post in the line, he was installing same part and was only told to put glove before working on the Audi ones, basically to avoid leaving fingerprints somewhere most customers would never ever look anyway.

[Perepiska]

Toyota Aygo

Also called: Citroën C1 (2005–2022) Peugeot 107 (2005–2014) Peugeot 108 (2014–2021)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Aygo

[rasz]

DQ250/DQ350/DQ500 are absolute beasts, what exactly is it that you dont like about them?

[newaccount74]

To be honest, I just once drove a Sharan with DSG for a day, and I hated the way it handled when parking and driving slowly. It felt like the worst parts of driving an automatic combined with the worst parts of driving a manual.

[comprev]

My mk1 TT is based on the mk4 "platform" so can use spare parts from Golf, Jetta, Ibiza, etc. Plenty of cars used the 1.8T engine too which is handy.