[testacct22]

> The bottom line us that these 3 businesses make money. Billions per quarter. It's coming in so fast they quite literally dont know what to do with it all.

Revenue might be going up, but are they actually providing additional value to users? Or just gutting them more thoroughly?

I look at the amount of utility that Google's products provided back in 2013, and I look at how much they provide now. Can't say the improvement has been anywhere close to stock price

[sokoloff]

Are you measuring utility to people who were searching or watching YouTube in 2013 and 2023?

Or measuring the utility to advertisers on Google’s platforms in 2023 and projected into 2033, many of whom weren’t using Google ads in 2013.

Google didn’t give me individually a ton more utility (arguably less in search), but I think it did give their actual customers (advertisers) a ton more utility in aggregate.

[bruce511]

>> look at the amount of utility that Google's products provided back in 2013, and I look at how much they provide now. Can't say the improvement has been anywhere close to stock price

The stock price I'd not a reflection of utility. Its a reflection of future profit.

As a user, you are not Google's customer. Their customer is the advertiser, and the utility to them is just fine. Advertising on Google and Facebook delivers measurable returns, and if that measure is positive then people continue to do it.

[flybrand]

These companies feel like parasitic house guests, you let them in and things start disappearing.