Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by piaste 1105 days ago
> How quickly would public opinion change if Google decided to just shut off their service in the EU for a day?

Very quickly - against Google.

The fact that European citizens have critical business ties to Google (from GSuite to YT partners) is a sword that cuts both ways.

It means the EU can't simply shut Google down on a whim; but it also means that Google can't just throw a tantrum and put up a black page saying "we are PROTESTING because your EVIL GOVERNMENT wants to OPPRESS US by asking us to PAY TAXES and ALLOW COMPETITION". Businesses wouldn't stick around to wait for the next time they got randomly locked out of GMail and GDrive.

(Not that Google has given the slightest hint of having considered such a move, unlike, say, Meta.)

> The world runs on Google and forcing that to change seems like a step backwards at first glance.

"Well we have a dominant position, it would be a shame if that were to change" isn't a great defence when you're being specifically accused of abusing your dominant position.

2 comments

Not to mention why should anyone anywhere trust google at that point.
How does Google disallow competition? China managed to overtake the top spot for social media so it's not impossible. Europe just can't build, period.
>Europe just can't build, period.

Even if that were true, it's beside the point.

If another US company were able to successfully compete without Google's domination of the market then the grounds for enforcement fall away.

Would Europe still try to regulate Google if one of their companies invented GPT4 and is threatening Google search?