Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hawski 1107 days ago
Why inability to sort by controversial is seen as a positive?
1 comments

Prevents a community of people awarded for throwing rotten vegetables at people like Twitter and Reddit.

> I also notice that there is no such thing as sort by controversy

> This is one of the things I like about Tildes so far. An option like that is specifically designed for hate. I want to spend my time on these sites talking with other nerds about homelab stuff and niche 30 year old RPGs no one cares about. Not feel the urge to constantly validate myself by looking at comments people are metaphorically laughing at for being ridiculous

https://tildes.net/~tech/15v5/stop_trying_to_make_a_good_soc...

> An option like that is specifically designed for hate

This is very short-sighted, I feel. The controversial comments often have the most interesting discussions, and helps to avoid the issue of the top-voted comment being a popular, but incorrect, view/discussion where all the activity happens.

Some threads on Reddit represent an echo chamber and I like then to sort by controversial to check if there are also people with a bit more divergent opinion. I was not aware of this being a wider problem for people.