Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fabiensnauwaert 1114 days ago
Hey! Thanks for the balanced feedback, all totally valid.

(1) I'm self-directed in my learning and always knew what I wanted my teachers to do, but everyone's different. Definitely going to add more choice of content (and not just roleplay.) I have a very structured and successful program to learn English and will try to adapt what works well in it to Gliglish.

(2) You're right! The speech recognition and LLM layers are separate. I actually do have data about the quality of pronunciation, I'm just not using it yet. It's a matter of adding a layer to handle it. Basically, all the building blocks are here and I need to get them to play nicely together.

(3) It's the same issue as with ChatGPT on which it's built. Part of the progress will come from OpenAI or similar endeavors themselves, part from further checks on my end as in (2).

I just don't share your pessimistic view about the future of such tech though (well, if I did I probably wouldn't have started the whole thing! ) Once you put ChatGPT into a corner, there's usually no hope of it getting back on track. BUT with clear context and prompts on things it does well it's just incredibly useful! Again, is the glass half empty or half full?

As for this use case, there's tremendous value in being able to practice. Just talking to oneself in the mirror or journaling in a foreign language is already super productive and this is it… on steroids.

1 comments

Just talking to oneself in the mirror or journaling in a foreign language is already super productive and this is it… on steroids.

I agree that a working pronunciation "coach" could be highly useful. And a great distinguishing feature for the app, if done right. However right now the app objectively fails in that category. It is simply unable to tell me when I'm not saying things properly.

(Which I hope you will take positively. The main thing is -- you're doing it, putting it out there. Best of luck).

Yes, one step at a time :) Definitely high on the list, pronunciation is very dear to my heart.