Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by __sy__ 1106 days ago
Tbh, probably not. I'll give you a few thoughts for consideration.

Matter is a device-to-device protocol within a local Thread network. It's solid for getting one device to tell another device on the same Thread network to perform an action, retrieve data...etc. Since Matter is pretty consumer-centric, those devices are generally all contained within a home.

To remotely control those devices (i.e. what our API customers want to do), you sort of need a Thread border router to serve as an internet gateway. You can think of Google Home or Amazon Alexa as one of those. So in theory, you could get a reasonably standardized API to speak to devices via those smart home platforms, but you'll still have to deal with the fragmentation of various smart home platforms.

More problematic, you're still constrained by whatever APIs Google Home / Alexa...etc decide to make available and whatever device operations the Matter protocol also exposes. You could bypass the first problem by installing your own Matter-compatible device hub, but the goal of many of our API customers is to NOT have to deploy any new hardware.

Lastly, a lot of Seam customers need to integrate devices that are not covered by the Matter standard and probably never will (e.g. Access Control Systems).

context: I sat next to Grant Erickson and the Nest team that initially worked on Weave, which eventually became Thread. I still have close friends working on Matter implementation at Google/Amazon/Apple.