Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by virgildotcodes 1109 days ago
This is an appeal to nature fallacy. Rape, homicide, and infanticide happen in nature, is that a justification for us to do it?
2 comments

> Rape, homicide, and infanticide happen in nature

those can only happen within the same species

Cuckoos? Don't they infanticide other birds?
There are videos on YouTube of monkeys forcefully doing things to other animals and people which might be considered rape.
People do it regardless. It's not a justification, but it's also not a preventative measure to say "this is bad".

But in the grand scheme of things, I don't think honoring prey is even in the top 100 issues in terms of impacts humans have on marine ecosystems. Sorry if I sound belittling, but it does sound like this whole thing is more of a symbolic gesure than a means to really resolve the issues we have caused. That's why I don't take it quite as seriously.