Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dharmab 1113 days ago
How is your phone bill $125 - month? I have usage based billing and it's between $25 and $80 depending on my usage.
6 comments

https://www.cnbc.com/select/how-to-cut-your-cell-phone-bill-...

> In fact, JD Power told CNBC that the average cell phone bill is now $144.

If you are on a typical american post-paid plan I guess that is what you get.

that bill is probably for multiple phone lines in a household, and include extra for paying off device loans.
Meanwhile I'm sitting here rolling my eyes at the description of "free or $10/month" as my mobile bill is already less than $10/mo. I'm sure adding cell plans to Sunk Cost Fallacy would be a great business move for Amazon though. The more things they can tie to it, the harder it is to cancel.
Prime is $150/yr
Mine is $280/mo, but has 6 phones and 4 other devices. So ~$30/device is good? No phone cost in there, just service.
$100+ monthly phone bills often include the cost of the device, not just the service.
Yea but in this case it's not a good comparison since Prime Mobile is presumably not including a phone too. But maybe it will.
My AT&T bill is over $100/month. My dad's on the plan too but it's a good $100/month just for the service in any case.
I buy the most expensive retail ATT plan and it is $50 per line and it goes lower per line as you add lines. See “unlimited premium”:

https://www.att.com/plans/wireless/

With signature program and multi line discount, I pay $40 per line excluding all taxes, and $45 per line including taxes for 4 lines. When I had 5 lines, it was $5 cheaper.

My experience with AT&T is that even though the cost may be listed as $45 per line for multi-line (and notably $75 for Signature single line), that after taxes and fees it comes out to $90 for a single line on signature. Came out to an additional $15 per line back when I was paying for multi line, too.

These days I go with post-tax/fee calculated provider costs (in my case, Visible (Verizon) at $45 for deprioritized service). So I guess some qualifying customers like yourself can manage that…

Maybe price discrimination, but only applies after fees?

I was mistaken about the price for ATT. Looks like the pre tax prices are drastically higher for fewer lines than mine.

1 line is $85 per line

2 lines is $75 per line

3 lines is $60 per line

4 lines is $50 per line

5 lines is $45 per line

and after that, you have to open a new ATT account and start at 1 line.

So I can see paying near $100 for an individual ATT line. It actually looks like Verizon is cheaper now? You can get 1 line for $65 per month plus tax for 3 years if you switch to Verizon (I cannot tell what the price is if you are already on Verizon).