Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lucas_membrane 1119 days ago
All this song data has been standardized and revamped multiple times and these standards have been implemented in mp3 players to decode and display info about that to which you are listening. Waitaminute -- mp3 players can play lots of sounds, including non-song sounds, e.g. speeches, air-checks, phone messages, commentaries, advertisements, radio dramas or comedies, bird-calls of birds, bird-calls of hunters, podcasts, phone-taps, recipes, soundtracks for walking or driving tours, audiobooks of diverse genres, etc, etc, which are quite likely to be acceptably identified and described by various attributes other than those applicable to songs. However, humans find it easier to put square pegs in round holes than to rebilk Romeo in a day.
1 comments

But MP3 tags don't attempt to store a universally unique song identifier.

They live in situ with the file, and multiple encodings of the same canonical "song" may not be identical.