Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dragonwriter 1115 days ago
Verbs specify safety/idempotency guarantees for API-blind middleware, as well as whether (if either applies) a body needs taken into account; POST is not idempotent, SEARCH/QUERY is safe, and therefore also idempotent, but differs from GET in that that guarantee is body-specific.
1 comments
adql 1115 days ago
Might as well just say "ok now GET can have body" instead of all that noise
link
dragonwriter 1115 days ago
Won’t retroactively change things that support GET to support GET-with-body. A new verb makes it much more likely that anything that supports the verb supports the desired semantics.

(Of course, you could instead bump the HTTP version for support of GET-with-body, but given how HTTP/2 and HTTP/3 are defined in terms of HTTP/1.1, you’d need three new versions of HTTP for a change to core verb semantics. A new verb, again, is far simpler.)

link