Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by esperent 1116 days ago
.io is similarly problematic. Although at this point I think the best solution would be to retroactively set .io to mean Input/Output and give the Chagossians a new TLD.

https://tamouse.github.io/blog/politics/2019/10/02/why-is-th...

EDIT: it could also be argued that this controversy is beneficial for the Chagossians I guess. I didn't know anything about them until I purchased a .io domain a few years ago.
1 comments
TheCleric 1116 days ago
Do you not see the obvious irony in taking a people who were forcibly removed from their home so it could be given to others, issuing them a TLD, and now you're suggesting forcibly removing that from them and giving it to others?
link
dchftcs 1116 days ago
It's something they didn't really ask for, never meaningfully utilized anyway, and ultimately is an entry in a table on some servers they can't really care less about.

You can fantasize about the hardships the citizens suffered for the appropriation of the .io TLD and draw any analogy you want, but there are probably more pressing needs of the people you're not addressing by spending time to supply this sort of sympathy.

Worse, imagine a world where you actually advocate for the displaced indigenous people to care about this problem. Probably you'd be asking them to divert attention from real problems such as being able to afford food tomorrow.

link
TheCleric 1115 days ago
No, the real problems are obviously more important. I'm just pointing out the minor insult that echoes the major injury that would be this plan.
link
pxc 1116 days ago
That is really painful.

But if those TLDs don't even bring them any money and they're not named after something in the Chagossian's own language, do they even own them in any meaningful sense?

Aside from the right to return to their homelands, these people should be given some actual royalties from .io domain purchases. And then maybe also a new TLD that is more meaningfully connected to them and less likely to be hijacked.

link
esperent 1116 days ago
When I wrote that I wasn't imagining any forcing going on. Rather I was thinking about dialogue happening with the ethnic group in question to try and find a TLD that makes sense in their own language rather than English.
link