Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by samtho 1115 days ago
JavaScript is the most common language for building interfaces and being event-driven. These two aspects make it uniquely suited for hardware applications.

But even as a JavaScript (and specifically not TypeScript) zealot, I cannot get behind JavaScript on hardware. The reason we use C or C++ is specifically the control over the very limited memory and anything requiring a runtime or manages it’s own memory (a la garbage collection) is a non-starter. Firmware is written once and seldom updated. A node.js app is not a bad way to handle the server-side component on IoT given it’s event driven nature and access to low level constructs.
1 comments
HeyLaughingBoy 1114 days ago
What do you consider by "very limited memory?" The processor I generally use for my hobby projects has 16M Flash and 4M RAM. This isn't the 80's.

> Firmware is written once and seldom updated

Not these days where everything must have an App as an alternate frontend. Device Firmware Update was such a frequent request that we just made it a fixed-cost line item on our quotation forms when I worked at an engineering services company. Projects where the customer didn't want DFU were far rarer than the ones that did.

link
samtho 1114 days ago
My most recent project uses an STM32F030C8 which has 64Kb of flash and 8Kb of SRAM. This is actually a beefier STM32 than I usually go for but was cheaper and more available at the time of the design.

I didn’t say it was never updated. Every IoT project or company I’ve worked on or with has the ability to update firmware and a lot of development effort goes into making sure that can happen. I have not worked at any place that pushed more updates per year than I can count on a single hand. Everything goes through, often manual, integration testing (ad nauseum in some cases), and field testing before it’s even considered as a release candidate. Compare this to release cadence of a CI driven development team for the web and server applications it connects to that deploys sometimes multiple times per day.

link
HeyLaughingBoy 1113 days ago
OK. My professional projects tend to be very large, so an 'F030 would be rather small. One of my current projects is based on an STM32F769, although I think we're using the smaller 1Mb Flash version.

DFU shouldn't get used a lot, I agree, but when it's needed it's a lifesaver.

link