[pxc]

That's because

> I can juggle

is here shorthand for

> I can juggle at all; I can juggle at least some things

and the basketball case is only a counterexample to the much stronger claim

> I can juggle anything

But the argument about AIs reasoning has little to do with such examples, because juggling is about the ability to complete the task alone. When it comes to reasoning there are questions about authenticity that don't have analogs I'm determine whether a person can juggle.

[travisjungroth]

This thread is exactly such examples.

What would “not alone” mean? Do you think someone is passing it the answers? Of course it was trained, but that’s like cheating on a test by reading the material so you can keep a cheat sheet in your brain.