Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gavaw 1120 days ago
Is it shipped if it cannot execute under any conditions? Philosophical question I'm afraid.
3 comments
codnee 1120 days ago
The code? Yes

The feature? No

link
zorked 1120 days ago
The company that makes GTA was sued for content that was not accessible in the game.
link
brookst 1120 days ago
Anybody can sue anyone for anything. I could sue Rockstar for not having enough nudity in GTA; that does not imply guilt or lawbreaking on their part.

The suit you mentioned was settled out of court for a tiny amount, basically nuisance value, with no finding or admission of wrongdoing.

link
saagarjha 1120 days ago
They probably shouldn't have?
link
jen20 1120 days ago
> could have become reactivated later by the change of a single byte in an installed system.

Is that not a condition under which it could be executed?

link
Uvix 1120 days ago
Only if the application has code to change that byte. “It could be changed by a patch” doesn’t count as a condition under which it could be executed, because a patch can make any change it wants to. You wouldn’t say “there’s a condition under which Windows will wipe your hard drive and every visible network share” just because someone can write code to do that.
link