Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rrdharan 1127 days ago
The “standard library” often isn’t available in early boot scenarios.
2 comments

True, but there are plenty of CS books about algoriths and data structures.
Copying a convenient-looking one out of a CS book is how you end up with a bubble sort. Approximately nobody comes up with a bubble sort from scratch; it's obviously, gratuitously bad in a way that there's no practical reason to think of on your own. The sorts that people come up with without reference are usually insertion and selection sorts—those two were discovered before bubble sort.
Bubble sort occupies a weird space where people assume it's dumb and simple so it'll be the least code, but even insertion sort tends to beat it.
I mean yeah, bubble sort is basically insertion sort but weirdly pessimized in a way that makes negative sense. Giving it a catchy name has probably been a net harm.
Plenty of children come up with bubble sort as a sorting algorithm. It’s intuitive to go down the list swapping any pairs that happen to be in the wrong order.
It's also very intuitive to pick out a misplaced item and put it in the right position. In the context of physical objects (e.g. playing cards), it's even more intuitive to come up with a (two-way) insertion sort than a bubble sort.
Only if they never managed beyond first chapter.
Lifting sample code out of an academic text, now there's a winning strategy for rock solid stability, correctness, and performance!
It is at least on the world where being an engineer actually requires a degree, and not just because someone likes the word.

The real ones, the ones that write USENIX papers.

Converting those into code is not always trivial.
Depends on the quality of the degree.

Besides I would assume anyone getting ready for their leetcode assignments goes through them anyway.

Nah, it’s not. Correctly implementing algorithms is hard; it’s easy to create incorrect behavior on edge cases and performance pitfalls. I’m sure you knew about the Java issue from a while back, for example.
The standard library can be statically linked...
People who think this way haven’t written boot code.. I suppose you’re gonna link the c runtime too and it’s assumption of being a “process” under some “operating system”.. oh wait.

Compared to the rest of the task, writing a sort is pretty darn trivial.

This is true if we're talking about the first stage bios boot that needs to fit in 512 bytes, but there aren't any particular restraints on kernel size at the point in question. Link in anything you want, including qsort.