Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hunter2_ 1122 days ago
Presumably this isn't about things people are stuck with (skin color, etc.) but things they choose (laws, etc.) and while discriminating on the former should be illegal, discriminating on the latter generally shouldn't be. Although when scaled up to such a large group, I can understand the perception of being almost entirely stuck in a situation (because it's not an individual choice for practical purposes) even when it's not a protected class.
3 comments

> Presumably this isn't about things people are stuck with (skin color, etc.) but things they choose (laws, etc.)

That is weird. I was never asked to choose my laws. Maybe sometimes I can have an imperceptible influence by being able to vote on a person who might have some say in the laws.

What I'm saying is by far and large laws are things people are stuck with just as much as their skin color.

I never chose the law, I never ever voted for the ones who chose laws of where I live in, which is where I'm born.

I'm being discriminated based on where I'm born (and can't move from for many reasons): So it's the same.

If we were to draw a line in the sand between "impossible to choose" and "possible to choose" I think generally moving is possible. There could be a million reasons why you'd prefer not to (huge risks, desires to put your efforts elsewhere, etc.) but that doesn't make it impossible, and generally the concept of protected classes (i.e., things we don't discriminate by) applies to things that are impossible to change. Maybe you even need to break a law to move, but that's more readily possible than changing your skin color, gender, etc.
I get the risks: for example probably there is more bot attacks from my IP range (and I'm behind CGNAT anyway) as I live in a less-developed country where people install everything (including pirated software) onto their (generally Windows and Android) devices blindly, with lots of malware.

Then again, the argument still applies: that kind of discrimination (IP-based geoblock because more attacks originate from that IP range) is not so different from skin color discrimination (prejudging, say, dark skin colored people because statistically more dark colored people involve in crime etc.).

I get it, perhaps I admit might even sometimes do it myself (not against skin color, but other factors) but I still think it's wrong.

i also feel offended by european union's take on protecting my privacy by invading it. i don't feel protected at all. i. just want to be left alone, goddammit.

i feel offended A LOT on internet these days.

member when internet was free? pepperidge farm remembers.

> i feel offended A LOT on internet these days.

American, yeah?