Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by reacharavindh 1126 days ago
Indeed. Thanks.

I just bought a MacBook Air with M2 yesterday after careful evaluation of Framework 13 for my needs.

The tinkerer/engineer in me loves most things about Framework against the MacBook Air.

However, a big con was the lack of s2idle sleep and its impact on battery life. I use a Mac for work, and have been spoilt with a machine that lasts longer than a day, and reliably and fastly come back to life when I open the lid. Intel and AMD have crippled their CPUs to disable deep sleep states to prevent such bliss. I don’t want my laptop to lose power while it sits in my backpack and supposed to be doing nothing.

It’s a shame because it appears atleast the Ryzen CPU listed by framework claims to have almost caught up with the base M2. May be the younger version of me that had enough spare time to deal with unreliable sleep/resume troubles would have chosen Framework over the MacBook Air.

2 comments

> Intel and AMD have crippled their CPUs to disable deep sleep states to prevent such bliss

AFAIK it's not the CPUs, rather, the motherboards. I have two modern Ryzen systems; one supports S3 out of the box, the other requires some messing.

>It’s a shame because it appears atleast the Ryzen CPU listed by framework claims to have almost caught up with the base M2.

It really hasn't. Check idle watts, package watts under load, performance when unplugged, battery life, laptop chassis temperature. AMD's solutions do not come close.