Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by willeh 1132 days ago
Seems similar to the GDPR, which IMO has been a huge success.

I'm sorry that it will hurt your quarter of a million dollar pay checks. Here we value consumer protection and that's how things will stay.

If your perspective so Anglo-centric that you can't interpret EU administrative law then you will do well to stay out of that market.

3 comments

> then you will do well to stay out of that market.

Agree with you 100%.

I actually do this. I forbid non-U.S. access in my ToS, because I only do business in jurisdictions where I understand the law. Keeping track of 50 states is tricky enough, let alone all the other nations. So if you are in the EU I don’t really do business with you.

But I actually worry this isn’t sufficient. AFAICT the GDPR doesn’t require my consent to engage in a transaction with an EU citizen.

I can ban them in my ToS and they can use my service anyways subjecting me to GDPR. And I don’t understand GDPR well enough to properly implement it (like, don’t I need a registered agent in the EU or something?)

I can block the EU IP block and they can use my service anyways using a VPN, subjecting me to GDPR.

In fact, I’m not sure how to avoid doing business with an EU citizen. I’ve toyed around with putting liability for all damages, fines, and lawsuits on the user in an attempt to pass GDPR fines onto EU users who attempt to use my service without my consent, but I suspect that’s not going to stand.

So not exactly sure what I should do.

Im grateful where I live now does not have GDPR, and i'm saying that as a consumer.

They want to get something like GDPR but more protective to customers.

Would not call GDPR a success - no country wants to really copy GDPR in its current form at all

> If your perspective so Anglo-centric that you can't interpret EU administrative law then you will do well to stay out of that market.

It has always baffled me how popular the sentiment of 'We have to know the LAW to do business in the EU!?' is regarding GDPR in the EU.