Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Maursault 1127 days ago
> What is suffering?

Pain is one of the few sensations that is unmistakeable. If you think you are in pain, then you definitely are.

1 comments

If "pain" is synonymous with "suffering", then I suspect that using the latter term is a deliberate attempt to emotionally manipulate me.

Pain is a signal of impending damage/injury, or existing damage/injury that may well worse if not dealt with immediately.

All signals within a human nervous system can be mistaken in principle. Why would this one be different? Phantom pains that indicate no injury seem plausible.

> Pain is a signal of impending damage/injury, or existing damage/injury that may well worse if not dealt with immediately.

Pain is not necessarily associated with injury.

>All signals within a human nervous system can be mistaken in principle. Why would this one be different? Phantom pains that indicate no injury seem plausible.

What would phantom pain feel like? Would it hurt? Then it is incidental that it phantom and is nevertheless pain. If you believe you are in pain even if there is no stimulus associated with it, then you are in pain. You can not mistake pain regardless of whether it is "real" or not. What makes pain so special? It hurts, it is painful.