[brundolf]

> That's equivalent to Gmail storing all of your emails on your device in case you want to immediately pack up and move to another email provider. That is an extremely high cost (I have 55k tweets, that would be a nightmare to host locally) for an outcome that is very unlikely.

If your identity is separate from your Gmail account (as it can be with a custom domain, for email and for bluesky), this seems like a very plausible and desirable thing to be able to do. Just recently there was an article about how Gmail is increasing the number of ads in the inbox; for some people that might change the equation of whether Gmail's UX is better than it is bad. If packing up and leaving is low-friction enough, people might do it (and that would also put downward pressure on the provider to not make the experience suck over time)

And that's not even getting into things like censorship, getting auto-banned because you tripped some alarm, hosts deciding they no longer want to host (which has happened to some Mastodon instances), etc.