Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Osiris 1135 days ago
Are traffic infractions criminal? Violating some traffic laws can be a misdemeanor or felony while most are infractions. I don’t know if infraction is considered “criminal”.
2 comments

> Are traffic infractions criminal?

This is often actually an area where toubwill find conflicting info; public info provided by the California state courts says yes, they are, in California [0], while you will find other sources, including law offices, saying they aren’t. [1]

The issue is largely that they are structured as crimes in state law, but the manner of punishment available does not make them “crimes” within the purview of federal Constitutional protections, or federal statutory consequences for conviction of state crimes (e.g., in the immigration system.)

[0] https://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/CIP_AboutCriminalCases.p...

[1] https://www.shouselaw.com/ca/defense/infractions/

If all you get from the cop is a summons, it's not a crime but more akin to a civil infraction.