Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by obpe 1137 days ago
I see, I have never implemented those types of validations. We do religiously deploy the same validation on client and server to explicitly avoid the mismatch of client/server validation. Having the client submit "valid" input only to have server reject it is something we have run into. Having only client side validation is something I have never run into.

Also, in my opinion things like you suggest you shouldn't do. A password strength metre is only going to give attackers hints at the passwords you have in your system. And I have not see a caps lock on warning in forever. The only password validation we do is the length which is pretty easy to validate on client and server.
1 comments
yawaramin 1137 days ago
> A password strength metre is only going to give attackers hints at the passwords you have in your system

No, it's not. A password strength meter just shows you the randomness of an input password, it doesn't have anything to do with passwords already in the system.

link
zamadatix 1137 days ago
I'd agree with both takes on that it depends on the meter. Ones which truly approximate password entropy work like you say, however, for some reason, the most common use of such meters is to show how many dartboard requirements you've met while ignoring the actual complexity. When this common approach is used you combine "password must be 8 characters or more" with things like "password must have a number, symbol of ${group}, and capital letter" and the average password complexity is actually made worse for a given length due to pigeonholing.

In the full picture though, in terms of UI/UX, the meter seems like only a downside. In the dartboard use case it's great because it displays what's still needed in terms users work and think with signalling e.g. "you still need a number, otherwise you're all set". People don't really think in bits of entropy though so ll that really is being signaled by either a meter or a normal failed validation hint is "more complexity and/or length needed".

There may be good cases for using a meter while simultaneously implementing good password requirement policy I'm not thinking of though.

link
yawaramin 1137 days ago
If you Google 'password strength' the first result is https://www.passwordmonster.com/

This works like I described, it don't show 'dartboard requirements', only entropy. I think you've misunderstood what a password strength checker is. It's definitionally not a checklist like 'You need an uppercase letter, a lowercase letter, a number, a special character'. It's a tool which measures the strength i.e. the randomness or entropy of the password.

link