Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rpastuszak 1135 days ago
100% agree with you but there are different levels of complexity and the one I'm talking about is truly ridiculous.

Example:

OpenRTB + VAST chain (standards used for targeted advertising) required to display an ad on the site involve dozens of parties the user has no knowledge about. In fact before an ad is displayed on the page, there's no way of knowing who and how will be involved in processing your data. The consent is implied and opt-out is enforced poorly to put it mildly. That's the complexity I'm talking about.
2 comments
Entinel 1135 days ago
What you are doing and what you are saying don't match. Let's be clear here, I think this project is great and I don't want this to come off as a criticism of the project. It's a really fun idea and novel use of machine learning. That being said, the sponsored Youtube content you are targeting avoids all of the issues you are talking about. There is no fingerprinting, shadow profiles, or tracking. Youtuber says "video sponsored by NordVPN use code xXx360NoScopexXx for 50 cents off" and then the sponsor spot is done.
link
rpastuszak 1135 days ago
Correct, it is more simple than the OpenRTB auction chain, but not in terms of the logistics of creating this type of content. See the sibling comment for @falcolas for more details.

I should've used more examples but tried to keep it terse. Thanks for pointing this out.

link
falcolas 1135 days ago
Ironically enough, sponsored content quite cleanly omits all this complexity and lets content makers earn money.
link
rpastuszak 1135 days ago
The complexity here is to have to: 1) write, 2) present, and 3) edit a video segment selling a product you probably wouldn't bother mentioning to people if you had other options. It's not technical.

The alternative (for instance) would be an automatic system distributing the $$ I pay YT among the creators I watch. That's significantly less complexity for the end-user and the content creator.

link
falcolas 1135 days ago
> an automatic system distributing the $$ I pay YT

So youtube red instead? They split the creator portion of your subscription between the creators you watch (assuming they've setup the ability to get paid by YT). Worth quite a bit more than ad views too, last I heard.

link
Entinel 1135 days ago
This still requires you to pay which brings us back to step 1. You are also implying that the content creator does not use the product and would not mention it otherwise which is not always true.
link