Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mikeywazowski 1140 days ago
Other than for the fact that it's open source, is there any reason people prefer AHK to AutoIt?

I haven't used either for some time now because I don't use Windows much these days, but I tried both and vastly preferred AutoIt. I'm surprised that the author stuck with AHK when he says "AHK v1 was very, very bad.", when surely AutoIt was a viable alternative?

5 comments

Hmm. I checked it out and didn't really like it. Autoit feels dated, like something out of the early 2000s. By contrast AHK feels modern, fresh, and slick.

Sidenote: what is it with Windows developers and releasing freware that allows for commercial use but still holding on to not being open-source or at least source-available? The fact that this is still happening in 2023 is flabbergasting.

Re: "Autoit feels dated"

Being old by itself isn't bad. What's an example practical downside of its old style?

Why _should_ they? I can think of a dozen different reasons why not, flabbergasting is a bit of hyperbole.
In the modern software world, a basic trend is that if it's free and has no path towards monetization (ads, user data, premium editions/subscriptions, etc) it's open source.
Not being peer-pressured into open sourcing your everything is a virtue of the Windows ecosystem.
Sure, but the weirdness here is that the program is fully free to begin with, for commercial use even.
It's worth remembering that free and open source are two completely separate factors. Something could have restrictive licensing despite being open source, while another could have very free licensing despite being closed source.

Open source by itself simply means the source is readily available for reading, nothing more and nothing less.

Huh, I was under impression AutoIt was the enterprise (i.e. paid) version of AutoHotKey. I'm surprised to find out it's freeware. I never touched it because I thought I had to pay.
Couple of reasons: x5 times smaller executable, better peformance, much friendlier commune. AHK is fork of AutoIt.
This is the first I've heard of AutoIt.
Keyboard shortcuts