[smeej]

How is this an argument, though? This is true of every small town that has one major company in it. The huge majority of people in town work for the company, and people don't really otherwise have much incentive to live there.

[coldtea]

How does this refute the parent's argument? If anything, it just says how similar it is with the already problematic case of "one major company town".

And this is even worse, as it's not "one major company town" but "just a major company and nothing else town".