Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sunchild 5236 days ago
What are you basing this on? It doesn't jibe with the laws, as I understand them.
1 comments

I was talking about this story with a guy I know who is a lawyer specializing in IP. It didn't seem to me like it would rise to criminal prosecution and he agreed.
First, you determine the rule. Then you determine whether it ought to be enforced.

While you might be right that the authorities won't take on the criminal case, you and your friend are wrong about the question of whether this is a criminal offense under the law. It's at least a colorable case of intentional infringement in a commercial setting.

Whether it arguably could be or not, I think we both know this is never going to be prosecuted, which is why I agree with grellas' take on it.

(edited to fix grammar)