[panick21_]

I have done social service instead of military in Switzerland where we have the same system. In fact we have to do 1.5 years of before we are 30. I worked in at least 5 (old people homes and hospitals) different positions. In not a single one of them is it true to say the system couldn't function if not for the civil service workers.

Simply paying normal people to do that work would be perfectly reasonable.

> is far more valuable to society than the taxes they would pay doing some minimum wage part time job waiting tables

Yeah but most people don't actually work minimum wage jobs. Me as a Software Developer spend 6 month cleaning windows. While this was reasonable fun and low stress not sure my window cleaning experience has this great benefit for society.

> not experienced workers who need to be pulled away from their well paying jobs

You start your job one year later and therefore spend 1 year less doing it before retirement, not sure how this is difficult to figure out.