[jahsome]

I run a server. Chat signing isn't enabled. Upon login, the user sees a message along the lines of "chat can't be verified on this server." Reporting doesn't work. Everything else works just fine.

[aprilnya]

But can someone who got banned by Microsoft still join your server?

[jahsome]

Why would I want them to?

[aprilnya]

because Microsoft could get it wrong? isn’t that why we’re disabling chat signing?

[jahsome]

Since the feature has been implemented can you point to a single case in which Microsoft "got it wrong?" I'll even be generous and include the entire year prior to java's chat signing in which the feature existed on bedrock.

Spoiler: you can't because that scenario doesn't exist. It's a FUD bandwagon argument, nothing more.

[aprilnya]

then why are you disabling chat signing?

[jahsome]

I'm not.