Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by newaccount74 1147 days ago
I'm really happy that Möbius did the job that the Syncthing devs don't want to do themselves. It's the beauty of open source.

The only people who complain about it are those who think "open source" = "I get everything for free".
1 comments
sneak 1147 days ago
Closed source proprietary software is not "the beauty of open source".
link
newaccount74 1147 days ago
The SyncThing developers wrote on their website that they don't offer an iOS client because Apple doesn't properly support background processing. It seems that the SyncThing developers don't care about iOS.

But here's the beauty of Open Source: anyone can download the source code and try to get it running on iOS.

Now Möbius found a way to get SyncThing kinda working on iOS, and for a small fee you can install it on your iPhone. The wrapper they built around SyncThing isn't open source, but for Möbius customers that doesn't really matter. They just want something that works. And through the beauty of Open Source, someone was able to build it for them, and they get to make a little money with it!

link
sneak 1146 days ago
Yes, many proprietary software developers who don't respect the freedoms of users make money piggybacking (some might say parasitically) on open source software releases.

I'm not sure what this has to do with open source, however. These people aren't even part of the free software community, as they obviously don't care about software freedom.

link
vorpalhex 1146 days ago
It sounds like you are confusing open source with copyleft.

Copyleft is a great thing, but it's also fine for things to be open source and not copyleft.

I can use syncthing because of Mobius. If Mobius did not exist, I would either have to pay a bounty to get someone to port Syncthing or use something else. That bounty is more than $6.

You can still port syncthing yourself. Mobius is not stopping you! You'll have to pay Apple $99 a year, and you will have to handle the app store process, and all - but you can do it. Neither syncthing nor Mobius will stop you.

link
sneak 1146 days ago
Free software has nothing to do with copyleft. Neither does respecting the freedoms of the user.

I release all my software into the public domain; it's not copyleft at all, but it is free software, and it does respect the freedoms of the user.

link
newaccount74 1146 days ago
That's very nice of you.

Why don't you make a free iOS version of SyncThing? There's a lot of people out there who would appreciate it.

link